Tomatoes are their own beast in the garden. It’s true what you heard about the harvest being good, especially when your tomato plant turns into a hydra that you struggle to contain. With so many tomatoes on hand, where do they go? Well, we’ve got a few ideas!  

1. Chili

A simple way to unload all those tomatoes is to make fresh chili. Depending on how much you make, some recipes call for several cups of chopped tomatoes, meaning you can use a bunch in one go.

Photo by American Heritage Chocolate on Unsplash

2. Homemade Ketchup

With all those tomatoes lying around, it’s a good opportunity to look into a homemade ketchup recipe. Even better, you don’t need that many additional ingredients.

Photo by Ashkan Forouzani on Unsplash

3. Caprese Salad

Caprese salad is mouth-watering any time of the year, so with dozens of tomatoes on deck, whip one up for yourself or guests. Fresh tomato slices with thick pieces of cheese and some balsamic drizzle? Yes, please.

Photo by Bryony Elena on Unsplash

4. Tomato Soup

Forget the stuff from the can! Fresh soup takes about an hour and though it calls for more time and ingredients than other recipes, it’ll be worth it for the end result.

Photo by Farhad Ibrahimzade on Unsplash

5. Freeze Them

You can always freeze tomatoes if you’re unsure what to do with your harvest. You’ll need to remove the stem, wash, and dry them first. After that, stick them in a freezer bag and squeeze out as much air as you can before you lay them flat in the freezer—they’ll last for months!

Photo by Josephine Baran on Unsplash

6. Fry Them

Frying tomatoes is a great way to use up your stash, not to mention make a delicious side dish.

Drizzle with olive oil and sprinkle on some herbs before they go in the pan. From there it only takes about five minutes until they’re done. Alternatively, you can also coat them in breadcrumbs first.

Photo by Alex Ghizila on Unsplash

7. Bruschetta

Just about everyone’s go-to appetizer is bruschetta. With so many tomatoes at your disposal, now’s the perfect time to try your hand at making it yourself. You won’t need much outside of fresh bread, tomatoes, cheese, and onion. Drizzle with balsamic glaze and you’re good to go!

Photo by Margarita Zueva on Unsplash

8. Gazpacho

With summer right around the corner, the mood calls for a cooler dish. Enter gazpacho. This summertime favorite doesn’t need a lot of your time or additional ingredients, but it will need your tomatoes. 

Photo by Bakd&Raw by Karolin Baitinger on Unsplash

9. Puree

Tomato puree has many uses: it’s a base for salsa, can thicken sauce, and is good in dinner staples like stews or casseroles. It’s simple to make and good to keep on hand while you think of what recipes come next.

Photo by Fidel Fernando on Unsplash

10. Pasta Sauce

Of course, we can’t leave out fresh pasta sauce. And why would we, with so many variations available? Borrow a recipe from your mother-in-law or try one you spotted online—everyone has a pasta sauce recipe and you should join the party.

Photo by Danijela Prijovic on Unsplash

11. Donate Them

Does anyone in your family or friend group crave fresh tomatoes of their own?

Donate some to ensure everyone has a chance to create in the kitchen. 

Photo by Roychan Kruawan on Unsplash

12. Seasoned Tomatoes

Sometimes the best thing is to sprinkle some seasoning and olive oil and just eat them! Seasoned tomatoes work great with whatever kind you grow, though we like cherry tomatoes for this one.

Photo by Anastasiia Chepinska on Unsplash

13. Grill Them

Pop ‘em onto the grill for a summer side dish. With a little olive oil, it doesn’t take much to grill these to perfection, and once they’ve got their charcoal branding you’ll taste the explosion of flavor. 

Photo by Tolga Ahmetler on Unsplash

14. BLTs

If you think about it, BLTs are perfect any time of the day—and with that in mind, now’s the time to make one whenever the mood strikes! Keep it simple or add fresh egg or avocado in there to make your own version.

Photo by Zachary Spears on Unsplash

15. Bloody Mary

Gone are the days of ordering these at the bar. Grab your salt, pepper, cucumber, and Worcestershire sauce to make a refreshing Bloody Mary mix in your very own kitchen. 

Photo by Misunderstood Whiskey on Unsplash

16. Stuffed Tomatoes

Stuffed peppers are great, but these tomatoes have to go somewhere. It’s time to swap out the pepper for your fresh tomato, especially because everything else can pretty much stay the same. You don't have to change too much in terms of what you stuff in there, thereby putting your own spin on this classic recipe.

Photo by Vince Lee on Unsplash

17. Tomato Pie

You’ve heard of shepherd’s pie, you’ve heard of chicken pot pie, but have you ever heard of tomato pie? Well, it’s a thing…a delicious thing filled with cheese and tomatoes and all wrapped in a flaky crust.

Photo by Clay Banks on Unsplash

18. Hot Sauce

We’d all like to try our hand at hot sauce, so why not make it a reality? Much like pasta sauce, you can go hog wild and make the recipe your own. It might take a little trial and error, but all good things do.

Photo by Sticker Mule on Unsplash

19. Chicken Parmesan

How could we turn our backs on chicken parm? It’s rich, it’s full of cheese and juicy chicken…and best of all, it can help rid some of those tomatoes should you make your own sauce or roast cherry tomatoes. 

Photo by Clark Douglas on Unsplash

20. Eat Them Whole

There’s no shame in chowing down on what you worked so hard to grow. Get in there! Do it quickly, too, because more tomatoes are probably ready for harvest as we speak.

Photo by Yves Deploige on Unsplash